Smart Innovation

 

Sustainable Growth:

Venture Strategies

Spinouts

Managing Innovation Separately through Creating External Start-Ups

By: Vadim Kotelnikov

Founder, Ten3 Business e-Coach Inspiration and Innovation Unlimited!

 

 

"In the existing business, it is the existing that is the main obstacle to entrepreneurship... If an entrepreneurial business is placed inside an established management system, it is more than likely to fail."

 ~ Peter Drucker

 

Corporate Venture Strategies Spin-outs Case in Point: Thermo Electron Corporation Ten3 Business e-Coach: why, what, and how 1000ventures.com Case Studies Spinouts

5 Critical Success Factors for New Ventures

By Peter Drucker

  • For in-company ventures in an established business, insulating the new venture from the main business... More

Spin-Outs / Spinouts Case Study: Thermo Electron - Managing Radical Innovation

Features of Established Companies that Prevent Successful Implementation of Entrepreneurial Ideas Internally

  • Policies, people, and practices build along set lines

  • Lack of motivation due to highly structured rewards schemes

  • Return-on-investment targets

  • Lack of clear accountability for the venture

Benefits of Spinouts

  • Higher flexibility

  • Analyzing all the available opportunities and selecting the best one

  • Exploiting the chance to create a new, profitable business

  • Better staff motivation and incentive compensation

  • Area of pioneering offering entrepreneurs a large degree of creativity

  • Tax benefits

 

Problems Faced by Spinouts

  • Jealousy by employees who do not get to be a part of the new internal enterprise

  • Weaker access to corporate resources. "Isolating innovation from mainstream business can produce a dangerous cultural side effect: Creativity and Leadership can be perceived as opposites. This artificial disconnect means that innovators often lack the visibility and clout to compete for the resources necessary for success," says Craig Wynett from Procter & Gamble.

  • Accounting for a buyout by the parent of the minority shareholders (who are the founders, management, and employees)

 Discover more!

Corporate Venture Strategies

Technology Commercialization: Venture Options

Radical Innovation

Managing New Ventures

Venture Management versus Corporate Management

Radical Project Management

Implementing Projects through Spinouts

Case Studies

Thermo Electron

Bunsha

Sun Tzu's "The Art of War": The Five Things You Should Know To Win

You must know five things to win:

  • Victory comes from having a capable commander and the government leaving him alone... More

The Need for Managing Innovation Separately

A new product or service may be launched either from within an established management system or from a brand-new operation. In both cases, autonomy is a precondition of success however.

 

Innovation needs to be managed separately as the established company would load insupportable burdens on the new venture: burdensome examples include highly structured reward schemes, return-on-investment targets, and lack of clear accountability for the venture. There is the fundamental difficulty in converting a large and/or non-flexible organization, which has built up policies, people, and practices along set lines, into the anarchic modes of the entrepreneur. To picture the problem, just imagine you forcing your right leg to run while your left leg and the rest of your body keep walking.

"The most important caveat is not to mix managerial units and entrepreneurial ones" in any way. Venture values are different from established corporate values. Technology spinouts are designed to provide independence and space for action and allow management to enhance market capitalization.

Entrepreneurial management of the venture-building process is fundamentally different  from corporate management that is focused on delivering the annual operating plan. Not only must "the entrepreneurial, the new" be organized completely separately from "the old and existing", but "there has to be a special locus for the new venture within the organization, and it has to be pretty high up". However small the new ventures may be in relation to its parent, "somebody in top management must have the specific assignment to work on tomorrow as an entrepreneur and innovator" and be responsible for developing and implementing corporate venture strategies.

Entrepreneurial Leader: 4 Attributes

Managing Innovation through Spin-outs

By 2000, internal start-ups, a new form of creating and financing a high-tech company has become more popular. This novel approach has a number of advantages over a merger or acquisition and it plays an increasingly high role for high-tech companies.

A spin-out enterprise differs from a spin-off. Spinouts remain closely tied to the company that developed them. In most cases, the ties are both financial and operational. Financial ties can be enforced through interlocking of stock ownership and financial oversight by the parent company. Operational ties may include shared professional and administrative services as well as marketing and leadership support.

New ventures established as independent companies can more readily fulfill their potential. In this case, the entrepreneurs do not have to argue with superiors or put up with interference.

 Success Story  Spinout Model by Thermo Electron Corporation (USA)

 

Due to its spinout model, from 1983 through 1995, revenues of Thermo Electron Corporation grew from US$ 200 million to US$ 4 billion.5 The company has created 23 spinouts and diversified from a single-product company to a multi-product corporation. It had made multimillionaires of forty executives and spinout managers... More

 Success Story  Bunsha (Japan)

Bunsha means company division. In practice in means routinely spinning off companies from the core group.

Kuniyasu Sakai and his partner, Hiroshi Sekiyama, are legendary managers in Japan. In the process of creating a prosperous Bunsha group of companies, they discovered how to keep their companies on the cutting edge, their employees productive, and their clients happy, all at the same time. Their method is what Mr. Sakai calls bunsha (literally, 'dividing companies'), a system he and Mr. Sekiyama developed over more than 40 years of real-world corporate management. They created a group of more than 40 thriving, independent, high-tech manufacturing companies through bunsha (company division). Once a company is "successful," they fear that bureaucracy and complacency will set in. What do they do? They divide it... More

Managing Innovation through Internal Start-Ups

In contrast, the in-company venture enjoys the benefits of the company's greater resources, brand name and corporate image. Getting autonomy for a new in-company venture may help it operate more like an independent. But, Peter Drucker warns, established business is also "the main obstacle to entrepreneurship". Mastering of the new business systems approach to managing projects aimed at development of innovative products and services will help corporations to move with speed to capitalize on emerging technology and market opportunities... More

 

 

 

References:

  1. "Innovation and Entrepreneurship", by Peter Drucker

  2. "The Frontiers of Management", by Peter Drucker

  3. "Managing in Time of Great Change", by Peter Drucker

  4. "High-tech Start Up", John L. Nesheim

  5. "Venture Catalyst", Donald L. Laurie

  6. "Project Manager's MBA", Cohen E. Graham

New innovation training game!

Discover innovation insights!

Innovation Football

Innovation process as a football game!

 View an innovation case study presented as a football game