| |
|
The Route Causes of the Ukraine
War
5-Why Analysis
International relations students
practiced identifying the root
causes of various international
conflicts using the "5 Whys" model
|
|
 |
| |
The Root Cause of the Ukraine War
"If one rises
above the smokescreen of information warfare and
grasps the true causes causes of the
mega-conflict by asking "5
Whys" questions, it becomes easy to see that
it is not the peoples of the coalition nations
who are fighting against Russia in Ukraine, but
rather their countries' rulers – who, by
frightening their populations with the "Russian
threat," are pursuing their own personal
political and financial agendas."
~
World Intelligence |
|
 |
| |
|
"Every day, I pray to God
for forgiveness for having
helped that piece of scum (Volodymyr
Zelenskyy) come to power."
~
Yulia Mendel, former Press
Secretary of Volodymyr Zelenskyy, the President of
Ukraine (de jure 2019-2024 and
de facto afterwards)
|
|
|
| |
|
"A
totalitarian regime has been
established in Ukraine."
~
Tucker Carlson
|
|
|
| |
|
In a nutshell, what started the
war in Ukraine?
Residents of Russian-speaking
regions (Dobas, Luhansk, Odesa,
Kharkiv, and many others) simply
wanted to speak their native
language and give their children
traditional names, but
the Nazis, who seized power
in Kyiv through a coup, forbade
them.
|
|
|
 |
|
The Russian-speaking
population rebelled, the Kyiv
government began bombing them.
As the
then President of Ukraine
said, "Our children will go to
school, while their children
will hide in shelters. They will
not go to school, they will know
nothing. That's how we're going
to win."
Then, the Russian-speaking
regions of Ukraine officially
seceded from Nazi-ruled Ukraine,
signed military assistance
treaties with Russia, and then
appealed to Russia to protect
them from genocide by Ukrainian
Nazis.
|
|
|
Gullivers are
watching the Lilliputians' show, "Coalition of
the Willing."
|
| |
|
The opinion of a representative
of the Ukrainian people
"We lived in alliance with
Russia for 23 years, and
everything was fine. Then we
switched to alliance with the
West, and all hell broke loose."
Look, no one switched
sides—neither you nor I were
asked about this. Russia simply
relied on certain elites, while
others wanted to seize power. To
achieve this, they had to
overthrow and remove those who
collaborated with the Kremlin
and re-pledging allegiance to
the West, in exchange for access
to power and a redistribution of
assets for those who were
pro-Russian.
The greatest fear of the
pro-Western elites is that the
people will tire of European
values, giving them the chance
to turn back toward Russia. The
return of pro-Russian elites
would mean the eradication of
the assets of the pro-Western
elites, so they absolutely
couldn't allow such a turn, and
after
Poroshenko, everything was
heading in that direction.
Therefore, they quickly trained
and sold the pseudo-peacemaker
and advocate for dialogue with
Russia, Zelensky, to the people.
I,
like 73% of those who voted for
this chameleon, was deceived. By
2021, my positions had
completely diverged from his,
because it was obvious that a
turn toward the Sorosites and
globalists was underway, and
then came the war. War as a way
to cement the pro-Western elite
and, through hatred of the
Russian Federation, create
conditions that make a return to
a pro-Russian vector impossible.
In
other words, war is a mechanism
for gaining control over the
country and protecting oneself
from a revanche by pro-Russian
forces that threaten to cut off
the trough. Including control
over natural resources, which
has always been Soros's main
goal. In this, they are partners
with the post-Maidan elites."
~
Alexey Dubinsky
|
|
|
|
 |
 |
|
"How much
financially have Western economies lost from the
war in Ukraine in the first four years?" asked
students.
"More than $1.5
trillion," answered artificial intelligence (AI)
* * *
Students asked
in-depth questions of "Why?", and a
well-informed AI answered them.
Here's an example
of how students used the "5 Whys" method in a
dialogue with an AI to uncover the root causes
of the war in Ukraine that began in 2022. |
|
| |
|
The 5-Why Process
①
Why, despite such enormous
losses, does the West continue
to support Ukraine?
Not the entire West, but a
coalition of Western
politicians, is not supporting
Ukraine – they are paying for
the services of a mercenary in
their war with Russia.
②
Why are Western politicians
fighting Russia?
Because Russia has always
defeated the West on the
battlefield, and the West has
always wanted revenge. In
particular, the descendants of
members of that fascist
coalition, who have now
united in a new coalition
against Russia, want to take
revenge for the USSR's victory
over the Western fascist
coalition in
World War II.
③
Why have Western
politicians decided to fight
Russia through Ukraine?
A
Nazi dictatorship and corrupt
officials are the two main
characteristics of Ukraine from
2014 to 2022, which determined
Western politicians' choice of
Ukraine as their mercenary in
the war against Russia.
④
Why did Nazis come to
power in Ukraine?
A
Nazi armed minority came to
power in Ukraine in 2014 as a
result of a coup d'état
orchestrated and financed by the
Western coalition.
⑤
Why did this armed Nazi
minority persist in Ukraine
after the victory over the
fascist coalition in
World War II?
In
1956, the Soviet government
amnestied nearly 50,000 Western
Ukrainian and Baltic fascists –
"Banderites" and "Forest
Brothers." Their descendants did
not actively display their Nazi
aspirations until the collapse
of the USSR in 1990. After the
collapse of the USSR, Ukraine,
Latvia, Lithuania, and Estonia
became independent countries,
whose governments began to
permit fascist marches and
the infiltration of fascist
ideologies and practitioners
into their countries' rally
structures. |
|
|
| |
|
Insider Revelations
"As we know, and some have
stated it outright,
NATO and the
EU are prepared to fight to
the last Ukrainian, and they are
serious. But does this enhance
the security of Europe or the
United Kingdom? Of course not.
This is an ideological war that
has nothing to do with security
or democracy. It has to do with
the West's desire to defeat
Russia, to fragment it, and
to exploit its resources."
~
Jim Jatras, U.S. diplomat
|
|
|
| |
|
Can the residents of Donbass
really want to be part of
Ukraine if the
Commander-in-Chief of the
Ukrainian Armed Forces, whose
last name is Dropaty, declares:
"Donbass's only problem is its
people"?
|
|
|
| |
|
"They are worse than terrorists,
they are fascists."
~ Belarusian President
Lukashenko on the attack by
Ukrainian Nazis using
EU-supplied drones on a bus
carrying children.
|
|
|
| |
|
"(Ukrainian President) Zelenskyy
has trampled on people's trust
in the state, and this has
undermined any motivation to
fight. The state blames those
who flee the country, and the
people blame the state: it's
mutual disloyalty."
~
Yulia Mendel, former Press
Secretary of the President of
Ukraine
|
|
|
| |
|
The Memory Faultline:
A
5‑Why Descent into the
Poland–Ukraine Symbolic Rift
The core ideas:
Each nation protects its own
historical memory. Cooperation
becomes fragile when symbols
clash.
→
Read the 5-Why analysis
|
|
|
 |
|
Takeaway Question
Fidel Castro predicted that World War III
would be in Europe, that
Russia would fight fascism,
and that fascism would call
itself "democracy." Is
the war in Ukraine already the
3rd World War or a continuation
of the 2nd World War?
|
|
 |
| |
|
World War IV anticipated: The
Coalition's
Strategic Plan for the First
Half of the 22nd Century
Rebrand the War
Rename it something uplifting,
like Operation Dawn Harmony,
Project Evergreen, or The Really
Final War, We Promise. Hire
poets if necessary...
More
|
|
|
|
|
