|
The Four
Perspectives Are Designed To Balance |
-
the internal and external
-
the financial and non financial
-
past performance with the future
|
|
Main Applications1 |
|
Implementing a balanced performance measurement system
can have far-reaching effects on your organization. It can be used for:
-
deciding what the key drivers of performance are
-
refocusing and stimulating activity on these key business drivers
-
drawing attention to goals and targets
-
creating a culture of achievement
-
noticing in advance any trends affecting the business so that changes
can be made in good time
|
|
Shortcomings of the Balanced Scorecard1 |
|
As the Balanced Scorecard (BSC) is not a multiple
stakeholder framework:
-
Suppliers are excluded: through
suppliers may be considered within the Process Perspective, this
approach does not give suppliers the visibility they now deserve,
especially in new business models characterized
by outsourcing of almost all non-core functions and
vertical integration
-
Regulators are ignored: many
non-negotiable standards have to be met, but they do not fit into
the Balanced Scorecard's framework.
-
Community and environmental issues are
missing: nowadays
environmental issues and local
communities are closely linked and companies need to measure and
monitor the impact they are having. If they don't, they may find
themselves subject to attack by pressure groups who can damage the
companies' reputation and ultimately destroy the business.
-
Competitors are ignored: Besides
shareholders and customers, companies need to monitor the
business
environment to track the competitor activity and
technology. BSC is designed to answer the efficiency question, 'Is
the chosen strategy being implemented?' but fails to ask the
effectiveness question, 'Is the chosen strategy the right strategy
for our business?' It does not monitor threats from non-traditional
or future competitors.
|

|
What is Balanced
Scorecard?
The balanced scorecard advocates a top-down approach to
business performance management, starting with business
strategic intent expressed
through the organization down to operationally relevant targets. The focus
with Balance Scorecard approach is on the link and/or influences between it
various components, which include business
strategy, perspectives, objectives, measures, initiatives and milestones
as well as softer contextual information.
Why Balanced
Scorecard?
To survive and prosper in
today's world,
companies can no longer manage using financial measures alone. You have to
track non-financial measures such as
speed of response and
product quality; externally focused
measures, such as
customer satisfaction and
brand
preference; and forward looking measures, such as
idea management and employee satisfaction.
The Balanced Scorecard is an important tool of your
strategic management system. It uses
performance measurements within a
framework of strategic hypotheses that enables you to learn what works best
in your organization.
Organizational
Balanced Scorecard
The organizational balanced scorecard
encompasses the organizational mission, vision, core values, critical
success factors, objectives, performance measures, targets and improvement
actions. This corporate scorecard is communicated and translated into all
business unit balanced scorecards, team balanced scorecards and the
performance plans of individual employees and their
personal balanced
scorecards. In connection with this policy deployment, each employee is
stimulated to contribute to the shared organizational strategy.
A Range of Strategic and
Operational Measures
The measures used to manage the performance of a business
comprise a range of strategic measures. The include the following:
-
Strategic measures:
market attractiveness (industry structure, growth, concentration,
innovation, customer power, logistical
complexity) and competitive strength (relative market share, relative
quality; intellectual property, customer
coverage).
-
Organizational measures:
culture,
leanness,
incentives, training and development, structure, purpose,
process.
-
Operational measures:
customer satisfaction,
product or service excellence, capacity utilization, capital intensity,
productivity,
outsourcing.
Depending on the emphasis placed on different measures in an
organization, its information and performance measures can vary between
operational fixed (for example, the 99% replenishment rate on the shelves of
a Sainsbury's store) and strategic flexible (for example, Microsoft's goal
of standards ownership on the information superhighway).2
29 Obstacles To Innovation
A Framework for Designing a Set of Measures
The Balanced Scorecard provides a framework for designing a
set of measures for activities chosen by you as being the key drivers of
your business. By having four distinct perspectives (financial, customer,
internal process and innovation and learning) it promotes a more holistic
balanced view of any organization. By creating your own measures under each
of these headings, no important area would be missed.
The Balanced Scorecards itself is just a framework and it
doesn't say what the specific measures should be. "That is a matter for
people within the organization to decide, and the set of measures for each
organization (or even sections within the same organization) will be
different. Much of the success of the scorecard depends on how the measures
are agreed, the way they are implemented and how they are acted upon. So,
the process of designing the scorecard is just as important as the scorecard
itself."1
18 Leadership Lessons from Colin Powell
Case in Point
Citigroup
At the heart of the Citigroup's Innovation Initiative was
putting the right
metrics
in place.
The Citibank Division already had an Innovation Index in place
that measured revenues derived from new products but that was deemed
insufficient. The special task force was challenged "to come up with more
meaningful top-line metrics that could be used to track progress and
could be integrated into the balanced scorecard, and ultimately tied to
compensation of senior managers. The team eventually settled on 12 key
metrics. They included such things as: new revenue from innovation, success
transfer of products from one country or region to another, the number and
type of ideas in
the pipeline (and expected new revenues), and time from idea to profit."3
Case in
Point
Using the Best Practice at GE:
The
Trotter Scorecard
Many
GE
business units employ a tool called the Trotter Matrix to check on their
use of best practices. The scorecard was developed by Lloyd Trotter, who ran
the Electrical Distribution and Controls side at GE. He listed six desirable
attributes for each of his plants and then scored each attribute...
More

|